If I Were a Dylan Roof Juror

I generally oppose the death penalty, for all the reasons we know: the penalty is applied disproportionately to minorities and the poor, who can’t afford decent legal representation. The penalty is irrevocable, and we know that false convictions are not rare. The penalty is barbaric, turning the state into an instrument of death. I’ve long felt that if I wouldn’t personally serve as part of a “strap down” team readying a prisoner for death, I shouldn’t expect others to serve in that role.

Dylan Roof challenges all of that. I think we’d like to say that anyone who holds his warped, racist views and acts on them to take the lives of nine innocent people has to be crazy. But he insists he isn’t crazy, and I take him at his word. We like convicted murderers to show remorse; Roof has none. We like to believe that even the most hardened criminal can turn his or her life around, and sometimes that happens. Governor Cuomo just commuted the sentence of Judith Clark, who drove the car in a Brinks robbery in 1981 in which a guard and two police officers were killed. Clark was a raving revolutionary when convicted. She has, by all accounts of people who’ve known her in prison, achieved that rare state of personal redemption. Maybe it could happen for Dylan Roof too, over time, and maybe that would be worth something for humanity.

The state expends a lot of money and time leading up to an execution; the appeals process is lengthy. The state also spends a lot keeping a prisoner incarcerated for life, especially someone so young as Dylan Roof. I don’t believe his execution would have a deterrent effect; people who hold warped, racists views will continue to hold them, and some will act on them. The families of the people he murdered have mostly forgiven him, although I believe their forbearance is being tested by his in-your-face lack of contrition. So has Mother Emmanuel Church forgiven him, although Roof thrust a dagger into the heart of that congregation, and healing will take a long time.

What would I do, were I a juror in this case? I’d really struggle. I’d really be deeply affronted by his attitude, and pained by the destruction he’s caused in so many decent lives. At the same time, I have a visceral repugnance at using the death penalty as a form of retribution. In the end, I’m not sure how I’d vote.

And you?

8 thoughts on “If I Were a Dylan Roof Juror

  1. I have long opposed the death penalty for both moral and practical reasons. Therefore, I do not want him to get the death penalty. However, having said that, I must admit that my less charitable side also thinks he would “suffer” more with life in prison. Not all of his fellow prisoners would be as forgiving as the congregation of the church where he carried out his dastardly deed.

  2. for Ada: I thought of that as well — the ultimate irony is Roof spending life in prison with a preponderance of black and Latino inmates crowding up against him.

  3. I have had the same discussion with myself. I, too, totally oppose the death penalty for all the reasons you list, plus the “Christian” argument that it lacks any element of compassion. However, I can imagine voting for death for him — if I were on that jury, being overcome with disgust for him as someone trying to pass as a human being. Still, I would make the argument that a life in solitary confinement is what he
    “deserves.”

  4. for Louise: I’m afraid I would be so repulsed by his lack of remorse that I’d vote for the death penalty.

  5. for Ada: I wonder if he survives in prison, in the general population if that’s where he wound up. I’m not sure.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s